Peace Processing

Did George Mitchell threaten to cut off Israeli aid?

There are reports this morning that George Mitchell, the Obama administration's Middle East envoy, threatened to cut off U.S. aid to Israel if the Jewish state blocks final status talks with the Palestinians. (The original source for these reports appears to be this Yedioth Ahronoth story.)

Certainly makes for a compelling headline -- but there's much less here than the headline suggests. If you read his remarks, Mitchell said only that the U.S. could, in theory, cut off aid to Israel. That's thoroughly uncontroversial! The question is whether the U.S. would cut off Israel.

If you think that's possible, then I have a bridge in Brooklyn I'd like to sell you.

Mitchell is headed back to the region within the next week or two. He'll probably stop in Cairo, Riyadh and Amman, in addition to Jerusalem and Ramallah. As we reported earlier this week, he's trying to convince Israeli president Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas to resume talks on borders. Mitchell (and the Obama administration) want to conclude those talks within nine months, before Netanyahu's ten-month partial settlement freeze ends.

Mitchell met in Washington yesterday with the Egyptian and Jordanian foreign ministers, as did U.S. secretary of state Hillary Clinton. Here's what Clinton said about the borders/settlements issue after her meeting with Jordanian FM Nasser Judeh:

And as Minister Judeh and I discussed earlier, resolving borders resolves settlements; resolving Jerusalem resolves settlements. So I think we need to lift our sights, and instead of being - looking down at the trees, we need to look at the forest. Where are we headed together? We know what a final resolution will have to include: borders, security, Jerusalem, refugees, water. We know what the elements of this two-state solution must include.

And here's Judeh, who said "time is not on our side" when it comes to final status talks:

We've said it in the past: we've had too much process and not enough peace. What we don't need in the region right now is another open-ended process that leaves issues unresolved and leaves loose ends without being tied. So it's important. And yes, final status issues as the Secretary listed them are known to everybody, but if you sort out borders, if you resolve the question of borders, then you automatically resolve not only settlements in Jerusalem but you identify the nature on the ground of the two-state solution and how it looks like. And then all other things fit in place.

But this borders-first push is unlikely to find much support among Palestinians. Saeb Erekat, the Palestinian Authority's chief negotiator, told reporters today that Abbas will not restart talks until Israel fully freezes settlement growth.

"You cannot have discussions on borders while the territory you want to set up your state on is being eaten up by the settlements."

Abdel Bari Atwan, the influential editor of Al-Quds Al-Arabi, has a caustic column today (عربي) headlined "The Arab crawl to Washington." He argues that the Obama administration is desperate to achieve something on the Israeli-Palestinian front to make up for other setbacks in the Islamic world (in Iran, Afghanistan, etc.). And he predicts the administration will "put pressure on the weaker party" -- the Palestinians -- and force them back to the negotiating table without securing a complete settlement freeze.

2 Comments

No need for neo cons to lose any sleep tonight. They say these things partially to make it appear they are less biased in this conflict. AIPAC is firmly in the pocket of our political figures in this country. It will never happen in a million years.

If the USA cuts off aid to Israel then we should boycott all American goods and services. It is unconscionable to be pressurizing Israel in this bully-boy fashion.

Post a Comment

Mitchell comes home empty-handed

George Mitchell spent a week trying to coax Netanyahu and Abbas into a 3-way meeting with Obama in New York next week. But Abbas turned him down; the Palestinian leader insists Israel has to offer a full settlement freeze.

Erekat floats the one-state solution

Saeb Erekat, the chief Palestinian negotiator, speculated the the Palestinian Authority might start pushing for a one-state solution. This isn't a new negotiating tactic for the PA. But it should worry the Netanyahu government.

Fighting to a standstill in Mogadishu

Latest Iraq election results: Erbil, Diyala, Saleheddin provces

Suicide bomber kills 40 people in Lahore

Al-Akhbar: Our weekly brief

Peace Processing

Fallout from Biden's visit: West Bank sealed off; proximity talks appear stalled

Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas greets U.S. vice president Joe Biden in Ramallah. (Photo: AFP)
As Joe Biden wraps up his Middle East tour, Palestinian officials say they're unwilling to move forward with proximity talks unless Israel cancels its new construction in East Jerusalem; and the Israeli Defense Forces have sealed off the West Bank for 48 hours, reportedly for security concerns. Several people were injured and arrested in fighting at the Al-Aqsa mosque this morning.

Peace Processing

Biden arrives in Israel amid serious Palestinian doubts

Vice President Joe Biden and his wife arrived in Israel on Monday.
As Joe Biden lands in Israel, the Israeli government -- obviously keen to demonstrate that it's serious about restarting peace talks -- announced Monday that it will violate its West Bank settlement freeze and build 112 new homes in Beitar Illit, a settlement west of Bethlehem.

Iraqi Elections

Polls close in Iraq; media reports suggest strong turnout, relative calm

An Iraqi man on a bicycle displays his ink-stained finger after voting in Baghdad on March 7, 2010. (Photo: AP)
A handful of insurgent attacks around the country killed two dozen people, but Iraqi security forces seemed generally confident; the vehicle ban in Baghdad, scheduled to last all day, was lifted before noon. Anecdotal reports suggest a strong turnout across the country.