Stay Don't Go

Egyptian men complain that women can divorce them too easily

Well, this is rich. Egyptian men, who are allowed under the country's Shari'a-tinged family law to divorce their wives on the spot, have formed an organization to complain that a woman's right to get a no-fault divorce if she forsakes all her financial interests is "tyranny."

The law of unconditional divorce, or khol'a, passed in 2000, Al-Arabiya reports. In response, a man named Abdul-Rahman Hamed founded the Egyptian Organization for Divorced Men, which "rejects the law because it equalizes men and women and gives the woman the right to get a divorce herself, a right that was previously exclusive to men."

The complaints that Hamed and others register are almost comical in their backwardness, at least in the eyes of this American.

"Men are losing ground. In the past, a man had the upper hand. Now, the woman is acting as his peer. If he threatens her with divorce, she does the same. She might even divorce him without his knowledge," Hamed told Al-Arabiya.

""This shows that unconditional divorce is no longer done discreetly and is not the exception anymore. Women even brag about divorcing their husbands with their friends. This law is making women tyrannical."

Women are bragging about their divorces? Quelle horreur! God save us from independent women!

Hamed, of course, was divorced by his own wife, even though he tried to "straighten her up." He assures Al-Arabiya that he's not ashamed by it, but claims that most divorced men "are rejected when they propose to women as if they are infected with some contagious disease."

I'll save some of the other quotes for you to go read them on Al-Arabiya's Web site for a good chuckle. But let's take Hamed's criticisms seriously for a second. You might recall back in October when we wrote about how divorce was on the increase in Egypt. A government study found that 84,430 Egyptian couples divorced in 2008, an 8.4 percent increase from 2007.

Certainly, Egypt has a conservative, family-oriented culture that is witnessing an upheaval of traditional ways of life. Hamed says he's particularly horrified by older women, 75 and up, divorcing their husbands. Such a decision "ruins" years of family life, he says. His organization has written to a host of government agencies to get khol'a repealed.

This illuminates a fundamental difference between conservative Muslim societies and the West, where the idealization of personal freedom has been in vogue for more than 300 years. In the United States, for instance, we consider a woman's individual freedom to divorce (or get an abortion) more important than enforcing the continuity (or creation) of families. Our loyalty to individual freedom runs so deep that an article such as this can only seem comical.

There's something to be said for strong families holding together the fabric of a society and raising children. Many Muslims, not to mention Christians from more conservative societies in Africa, Central America and elsewhere, would argue that there are serious downsides to the way the United States elevates personal freedom and the correlated pursuit of personal wealth.

But if a government's first objective should be to not harm its citizens, then an opening, rather than restricting, of laws of personal freedom should be in order. That is, unless Egyptians believe that their women are not capable of making decisions in their best interest.

No Comments

Post a Comment

More Egyptians divorcing, not getting married at all

Newly released statistics show a significant jump in the number of divorces in Egypt, and reveal that at least a fifth of the population 30 years or older has never been married at all.

Egypt's State Council bars women from judicial positions

Egypt's State Council voted 334-42 earlier this week to bar women from holding judicial positions. Roughly 30 women work on the council, which advises ministries and adjudicates lawsuits against the government.

Indirect talks that ignore the settlements, or, party like it's 1991

Allawi, Chalabi allege voter fraud in Iraq

High moral principle in Israel

Al-Akhbar: Our weekly brief

Peace Processing

Fallout from Biden's visit: West Bank sealed off; proximity talks appear stalled

Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas greets U.S. vice president Joe Biden in Ramallah. (Photo: AFP)
As Joe Biden wraps up his Middle East tour, Palestinian officials say they're unwilling to move forward with proximity talks unless Israel cancels its new construction in East Jerusalem; and the Israeli Defense Forces have sealed off the West Bank for 48 hours, reportedly for security concerns. Several people were injured and arrested in fighting at the Al-Aqsa mosque this morning.

Peace Processing

Biden arrives in Israel amid serious Palestinian doubts

Vice President Joe Biden and his wife arrived in Israel on Monday.
As Joe Biden lands in Israel, the Israeli government -- obviously keen to demonstrate that it's serious about restarting peace talks -- announced Monday that it will violate its West Bank settlement freeze and build 112 new homes in Beitar Illit, a settlement west of Bethlehem.

Iraqi Elections

Polls close in Iraq; media reports suggest strong turnout, relative calm

An Iraqi man on a bicycle displays his ink-stained finger after voting in Baghdad on March 7, 2010. (Photo: AP)
A handful of insurgent attacks around the country killed two dozen people, but Iraqi security forces seemed generally confident; the vehicle ban in Baghdad, scheduled to last all day, was lifted before noon. Anecdotal reports suggest a strong turnout across the country.