Scare quotes

The New York Times writes up Ali Akbar Salehi's press conference under the headline Iran Insists on Its 'Rights' to Nuclear Program. I'm not quite sure why we need the scare quotes there. Iran has a right to a nuclear program. Period. It doesn't have a right to a nuclear weapons program, but then Salehi isn't asserting that right. (Whether the Iranian government is pursuing one is another question entirely.)

1 Comment

Here's directly from the text of the NPT:

1. Nothing in this Treaty shall be interpreted as affecting the inalienable right of all the Parties to the Treaty to develop research, production and use of nuclear energy for peaceful purposes without discrimination and in conformity with articles I and II of this Treaty.
Here's George Perkovich, from your link that Iran has a right to a nuclear program.
Iran, like all countries, has a right to “develop research, production and use of nuclear energy for peaceful purposes…in conformity with Articles I and II of the Treaty” Under Article IV of the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty, Iran can expect international cooperation in exercising such rights.
Perkovich skipped "without discrimination", and only those two words. Was he really that pressed for space or is he trying to avoid what "without discrimination" implies? Because Japan and Brazil reprocess or enrich and in both cases could make a political decision to make weapons with technology and materials in the country now. I'm not sure how Perkovich claims Iran does not have a right to enrich if this right applies without discrimination. But even worse, why snip it out? Why not face the fact.

Just pointing this out.

Post a Comment

Will Salehi bring change?

It's true that Iran cooperated with the IAEA during Salehi's tenure. Salehi wasn't the reason for that cooperation, though; it came from then-president Mohammad Khatami, who took a political risk by working with the IAEA.

Nuclear family

It's always difficult to know what's really happening inside Iran's opaque political system. With that caveat, let's try to unpack two articles about the changing leadership of Iran's nuclear program.

Petraeus: Israeli-Arab conflict endangering U.S. interests

Latest Iraqi election results: Baghdad, Muthanna, Ninewa, Qadisiyah provinces

Explosions in Kandahar leave dozens dead and wounded

Al-Akhbar: Our weekly brief

Peace Processing

Fallout from Biden's visit: West Bank sealed off; proximity talks appear stalled

Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas greets U.S. vice president Joe Biden in Ramallah. (Photo: AFP)
As Joe Biden wraps up his Middle East tour, Palestinian officials say they're unwilling to move forward with proximity talks unless Israel cancels its new construction in East Jerusalem; and the Israeli Defense Forces have sealed off the West Bank for 48 hours, reportedly for security concerns. Several people were injured and arrested in fighting at the Al-Aqsa mosque this morning.

Peace Processing

Biden arrives in Israel amid serious Palestinian doubts

Vice President Joe Biden and his wife arrived in Israel on Monday.
As Joe Biden lands in Israel, the Israeli government -- obviously keen to demonstrate that it's serious about restarting peace talks -- announced Monday that it will violate its West Bank settlement freeze and build 112 new homes in Beitar Illit, a settlement west of Bethlehem.

Iraqi Elections

Polls close in Iraq; media reports suggest strong turnout, relative calm

An Iraqi man on a bicycle displays his ink-stained finger after voting in Baghdad on March 7, 2010. (Photo: AP)
A handful of insurgent attacks around the country killed two dozen people, but Iraqi security forces seemed generally confident; the vehicle ban in Baghdad, scheduled to last all day, was lifted before noon. Anecdotal reports suggest a strong turnout across the country.