Blogging the Goldstone Report

A Middle East history lesson

This entry is part of an ongoing series, Blogging the Goldstone Report.

Today's installment of the Goldstone Report (p. 39-70, if you're following along at home) is slightly boring compared to yesterday's executive summary. This section provides more detail on the report's methodology and a broad history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

It begins with some background on the team members: Richard Goldstone, a former South African judge; Christine Chinkin, a professor at the London School of Economics; Hina Jilani, the advocate of the Supreme Court of Pakistan; and Col. Desmond Travers, a former officer in Ireland's Defence Forces.

The team points out that it was operating under a very limited timeframe -- about three months. So it cautions that this report is not an exhaustive review of every allegation leveled against Israel and Hamas.

Goldstone mentioned in the executive summary that the Israeli government "did not cooperate" with the mission. Today's section elaborates on that claim: Israeli officials refused to meet with Goldstone's team, and denied them permission to travel to Israel and the West Bank. (They entered Gaza through the Rafah crossing with Egypt.)

The team wanted to interview Ali al-Khashan, the Palestinian justice minister, and Khalida Jarrar, a member of the Palestinian Legislative Council. But both were prevented from traveling to Amman to meet with the U.N. mission

The report also elaborates on the case of Muhammad Srour, the Palestinian detained by Israeli authorities after meeting with the mission in Amman.

In response, the Permanent Representative informed the Mission that the detention of the person concerned was unrelated to his appearance at the public hearing. Mr. Srour was subsequently released on bail. The Mission is in contact with him and continues to monitor developments.

Another unnamed source talks about "apprehensions about personal safety and a feeling of intimidation." The report doesn't provide any detail on who this person is or how this person feels threatened -- though it does say he/she provided information about what happened inside the Gaza Strip.

A 40-year history

Around p. 52, the report begins to examine the history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It begins its overview in 1967, immediately after the Six-Day War, which ended with Israel in control of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. The pages that follow will be familiar to any student of the region: Israel's annexation of East Jerusalem; the Oslo Accords; the Camp David Accords; the "road map"; the 2006 Palestinian elections.

The history ends with the tahdiyah, the six-month period of calm that began in June 2008.

The report notes that Palestinian terror groups carried out 154 suicide bombings against Israeli civilians between 1993 and 2007. The attacks left 542 people dead. Palestinians also launched 3,455 rockets and 3,742 mortars into Israel during that period.

Goldstone doesn't provide comparable statistics for the IDF. But it does note that, between Israel's disengagement from Gaza (August 2005) and November 2006, the IDF launched 15,000 artillery shells into Gaza and carried out 550 airstrikes, killing 525 people. Palestinians launched 1,700 rockets or mortars during the same period, injuring 41 Israelis.

Contours of the conflict

The final pages of the history section address the aggravating factors that led to Operation Cast Lead. One of them is Israel's ongoing control of Gaza's borders and infrastructure.

In addition to controlling the borders, coastline and airspace, after the implementation of the disengagement plan, Israel continued to control Gaza's telecommunications, water, electricity and sewage networks, as well as the population registry, and the flow of people and goods into and out of the territory while the inhabitants of Gaza continued to rely on the Israeli currency.

The report also discusses the separation wall, Israel's frequent detention of Palestinians (750,000 since 1967, according to Palestinian human rights groups), and the Israeli government's periodic demolition of Palestinian buildings in the West Bank. None of these are proximate causes of the war in Gaza, of course, so I'm not sure whether the mission included them simply to be thorough or whether they'll play a role in later conclusions.

Approaching the end of today's reading. Beginning on p. 66, the report outlines political structures in Israel and Palestine. It includes some detail about the Palestinian police and the "armed wings" of both Hamas and Fatah. I suspect these will come up again in later sections: You'll recall from the executive summary that Israel justified its attacks against Palestinian police stations by claiming the police were also fighters affiliated with Hamas.

That's it for today! Tomorrow's section deals with the tahdiyah itself -- the six months leading up to the war.

No Comments

Post a Comment

The Oslo fetish

Foreign Policy has a bizarre article this week claiming that, essentially, all Palestinians are now extremists because they now reject the Oslo Accords. But most Palestinians, and most Israelis, rejected Oslo years ago.

Hamas under pressure to probe its Gaza war crimes

A coalition of Palestinian human rights groups wants Hamas to investigate its misdeeds during Operation Cast Lead, and Aharon Barak -- the former head of the Israeli supreme court -- wants the attorney general to investigate the IDF.

Fighting to a standstill in Mogadishu

Latest Iraq election results: Erbil, Diyala, Saleheddin provces

Suicide bomber kills 40 people in Lahore

Al-Akhbar: Our weekly brief

Peace Processing

Fallout from Biden's visit: West Bank sealed off; proximity talks appear stalled

Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas greets U.S. vice president Joe Biden in Ramallah. (Photo: AFP)
As Joe Biden wraps up his Middle East tour, Palestinian officials say they're unwilling to move forward with proximity talks unless Israel cancels its new construction in East Jerusalem; and the Israeli Defense Forces have sealed off the West Bank for 48 hours, reportedly for security concerns. Several people were injured and arrested in fighting at the Al-Aqsa mosque this morning.

Peace Processing

Biden arrives in Israel amid serious Palestinian doubts

Vice President Joe Biden and his wife arrived in Israel on Monday.
As Joe Biden lands in Israel, the Israeli government -- obviously keen to demonstrate that it's serious about restarting peace talks -- announced Monday that it will violate its West Bank settlement freeze and build 112 new homes in Beitar Illit, a settlement west of Bethlehem.

Iraqi Elections

Polls close in Iraq; media reports suggest strong turnout, relative calm

An Iraqi man on a bicycle displays his ink-stained finger after voting in Baghdad on March 7, 2010. (Photo: AP)
A handful of insurgent attacks around the country killed two dozen people, but Iraqi security forces seemed generally confident; the vehicle ban in Baghdad, scheduled to last all day, was lifted before noon. Anecdotal reports suggest a strong turnout across the country.